• @Prunebutt@slrpnk.net
    link
    fedilink
    24 months ago

    Are bolsheviks socialist?

    No. They were state-capitalists.

    He literally limited the profitability of companies to 6%.

    You agree that companies made profits. That’s a capitalist policy.

    He’s non-marxist socialist. Not all socialist are Marxists.

    I didn’t say whether or not he was a Marxist. All socialists apply Marxist analysis at least partially. Even Bakunin agreed with Marx’s theory.

    Btw, fascists are Marxists.

    🤡

    I’m not an ancap.

    You’re enough of an ancap for me to care how you define yourself. You’ve proven enough how little of political/historical understanding you have.

    • No. They were state-capitalists.

      Ok.

      You agree that companies made profits. That’s a capitalist policy.

      Considering what was before, it was a gradual step towards socialism. Nazi Germany existed for like 30 years. Not everything can be implemented immediately.

      All socialists apply Marxist analysis at least partially

      Uhuh. Is Charles Fourier socialist?

      You’re enough of an ancap

      What is that even supposed to mean?

      • @Prunebutt@slrpnk.net
        link
        fedilink
        14 months ago

        Considering what was before, it was a gradual step towards socialism. Nazi Germany existed for like 30 years.

        Ah, yes. And Hitler clearly stated that he was a socialist… somewhere. You have to read between the lines of “Mein Kampf”, where he clearly states that he’s right wing. And all the companies who profited immensly from all that slave labour where juuuust about to be socialised. /s

        Uhuh. Is Charles Fourier socialist?

        Got any proper points, or are you just gonna “umm actually” me to death?

        What is that even supposed to mean?

        You’re a weirdo who deserves to be ridiculed for having such a stupid worldview.

        • Ah, yes. And Hitler clearly stated that he was a socialist… somewhere

          I didn’t say it. Although he did.

          You have to read between the lines of “Mein Kampf”, where he clearly states that he’s right wing.

          Where?

          Btw are bolsheviks communists? Bc they clearly stated they are. No need to even read between the lines.

          And all the companies who profited immensly from all that slave labour

          And what’s the relation between capitalism and slavery?

          Got any proper points, or are you just gonna “umm actually” me to death?

          The point is that socialists can be socialists without applying Marx works in any way.

          You’re a weirdo who deserves to be ridiculed for having such a stupid worldview

          What worldview? What is my worldview?