I think you forgot a pretty crucial point, that it is also royalty free. Royalty would be a huge problem.
I have yet to see a general royalty free image format as feature complete and up to date as IFF was for the Amiga back in 1985. From your list, Jpeg XL would finally even surpass that. As a very feature complete format improving on at least 3 formats (GIF PNG JPG)while wrapping them into 1. The only thing missing, is to become universally supported.
I wonder how the Chrome team managed to test it so poorly they claimed it wasn’t worth it? Just the versatility alone should make it a no-brainer.
Why they went through all this trouble to kill a format that they themselves co-developed, I really have no idea.
I don’t know about AVIF, but WebP is a Google format, and they might be doing it for control, like they use control of Chrome to push more advertising.
deleted by creator
I think you forgot a pretty crucial point, that it is also royalty free. Royalty would be a huge problem.
I have yet to see a general royalty free image format as feature complete and up to date as IFF was for the Amiga back in 1985. From your list, Jpeg XL would finally even surpass that. As a very feature complete format improving on at least 3 formats (GIF PNG JPG)while wrapping them into 1. The only thing missing, is to become universally supported.
I wonder how the Chrome team managed to test it so poorly they claimed it wasn’t worth it? Just the versatility alone should make it a no-brainer.
deleted by creator
I don’t know about AVIF, but WebP is a Google format, and they might be doing it for control, like they use control of Chrome to push more advertising.
deleted by creator
Avif is pushed because it’s good and has hardware support across the board
What does google gains by making AVIF win rather than AVIF?
deleted by creator
But google also participated to the creation of JPEG-Xl.
And having “their” standard win does not make any sense to me to see where they benefit from it.
deleted by creator
ironic this image is in a PNG lol
This is truly amazing tbh.
Graph conveniently omits hardware support, where avif (av1) is supported across the board
deleted by creator
Funny enough, JXL is supported anywhere you have a general purpose CPU, which is anything consumer with a GUI!
It’s very slow on high compression profiles though, and consumes a lot of resources.
deleted by creator
I tried getting benefit from the format by recompressing PNGs at some point and it just seemed worthless due to reasons I listed in my comment.
deleted by creator